Automation vs Manual Labor...
What to think about...
Automation has completely changed how we think about manufacturing processes. Previously, manufacturers could depend on having a skilled labor pool to deliver many capable people to build their products. Recently with many of those same workers retiring or leaving the work force, manufacturers need to pivot. Automation typically is their preferred compass point.
Since 2008's recession, automated manufacturing has been growing exponentially across all industry markets. It is safe to say that the past fifteen of growth has proven that automation is here to stay.
For some businesses, their survival depends on it. As the work force dwindles for a multitude of reasons, these companies must adapt and overcome. If you're considering automating your processes, please read on and consider the factors below.
Automated vs. Manual Labor...
Overall cost is the most common starting point. Start by clearly defining your goals and indicators to track your progress/success. These may include: Profit Targets, Scrap Rates, Rework, or Uptime/Downtime ratios. These indicators are data based benchmarks you can refer to while determining if automation is best for your process.
Next collect as much data regarding all of the costs associated with Manual Labor and Automated Processes.
Costs of Manual Labor:
Wages (wage inflation)
Training (non-wage benefits)
Worker's Compensation Insurance
Payroll Taxes
Auxiliary Safety Equipment
Managers also need to consider the following intangible costs too. These costs are harder to quantify but they are just as critical data points in your decision making process.
Human Error
Safety Risk
Product Loss/Rework
Lower production rates
Automated Process Costs:
Up-front hardware and software investment including installation.
Operator Training and Wages
Ongoing Maintenance
Planned/Unplanned stoppages for change overs in flexible automation systems
Automated processes come with fewer unknowns/intangibles. They may not be better nor more cost effective processes. They can help businesses reduce their overall workforce maintenance costs due to high employee turn over rates and redundant training. Automated processes allow businesses to redirect their workforce into tasks where they can thrive.
Calculating Return On Investment (ROI)...
Automated vs Manual Systems:
Is the up-front cost of implementing an automated process going to pay off over the life of the system?
Replacing/removing hands can result in a cost savings that may offset the expense.
Product consistency (quality) and increased capacity directly effects the revenue potential that will out weigh the low cost, low volume manual system.
Often the combination of these two factors result in a positive ROI in the long term.
P2 Automation’s Approach…
We observe your current manual process. We listen to you, your machine operators, and maintenance technicians to hear and see what the problems are. Next, we walk through your ideas for automating that process, taking into consideration the upstream/downstream operations that will be effected. Then evaluate if the upstream/downstream operations can be incorporated into your solution.
Finally, we work through a concept that falls in line with your expectations and specifications to make the automated process (or manual process modifications) the most profitable for you.
P2 Automation stands behind everything we do. We support and service all of our systems in the field.